Find a store that carries our products!

Our Dutch Country Promise

From the heart of Amish country using farm-fresh milk and traditional methods.

No shortcuts. Just real cheese, made right.

Get your order fresh and delivered on time.

Enjoy premium taste in every single bite.

Friendly, reliable customer service you can rely on.

Shop Our Delicious Cheeses and More

Dutchman’s Special Premium Aged Cheddar Cheese

Dutchman’s Special Premium Aged Cheddar Cheese

$8.40
20 Year Aged White Cheddar - Limited Addition

20 Year Aged White Cheddar - Limited Addition

$16.99
Mild Yellow Cheddar Cheese

Mild Yellow Cheddar Cheese

$6.30
Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

$8.40
20 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar - Limited Addition

20 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar - Limited Addition

$16.99
Smoked Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Smoked Sharp Cheddar Cheese

$8.40
Horseradish Cheddar Cheese

Horseradish Cheddar Cheese

$7.35
Smoked Yellow Cheddar Cheese

Smoked Yellow Cheddar Cheese

$7.35
3 Year Aged White Cheddar Cheese

3 Year Aged White Cheddar Cheese

$8.40
Aged White Cheddar Cheese

Aged White Cheddar Cheese

$7.35
Mild White Cheddar Cheese

Mild White Cheddar Cheese

$6.30
Garlic And Herb Jack Cheese

Garlic And Herb Jack Cheese

$7.35
Smoked Onions & Chives Jack Cheese

Smoked Onions & Chives Jack Cheese

$8.40
Onions And Chives Jack Cheese

Onions And Chives Jack Cheese

$7.35
Havarti Dill Cheese

Havarti Dill Cheese

$9.18
Monterey Jack Cheese

Monterey Jack Cheese

$6.30
Garlic And Herb Jack Cheese

Garlic And Herb Jack Cheese

$7.35
The Jack Cheese Box

The Jack Cheese Box

$44.50
Smoked Onions & Chives Jack Cheese

Smoked Onions & Chives Jack Cheese

$8.40
Smoked Pepper Jack Cheese

Smoked Pepper Jack Cheese

$8.40
Colby Jack Cheese

Colby Jack Cheese

$6.30
Smoked Monterey Jack Cheese

Smoked Monterey Jack Cheese

$7.35
Pepper Jack Cheese

Pepper Jack Cheese

$7.35
Onions And Chives Jack Cheese

Onions And Chives Jack Cheese

$7.35
Smoked Creamy White American Cheese

Smoked Creamy White American Cheese

$7.88
Smoked Provolone Cheese

Smoked Provolone Cheese

$9.19
Smoked Creamy Black Pepper American Cheese

Smoked Creamy Black Pepper American Cheese

$8.40
Smoked Swiss Cheese

Smoked Swiss Cheese

$10.50
Smoked Pepper Jack Cheese

Smoked Pepper Jack Cheese

$8.40
Smoked Gouda Cheese

Smoked Gouda Cheese

$7.88
Smoked Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Smoked Sharp Cheddar Cheese

$8.40
Smoked Onions & Chives Jack Cheese

Smoked Onions & Chives Jack Cheese

$8.40
The Smoked Cheese Box

The Smoked Cheese Box

$74.50
Smoked Monterey Jack Cheese

Smoked Monterey Jack Cheese

$7.35
Smoked Yellow Cheddar Cheese

Smoked Yellow Cheddar Cheese

$7.35
Dutchman’s Special Premium Aged Cheddar Cheese

Dutchman’s Special Premium Aged Cheddar Cheese

$8.40
20 Year Aged White Cheddar - Limited Addition

20 Year Aged White Cheddar - Limited Addition

$16.99
20 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar - Limited Addition

20 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar - Limited Addition

$16.99
6 Month Aged Le Gruyere AOP Cheese

6 Month Aged Le Gruyere AOP Cheese

$32.49
3 Year Aged White Cheddar Cheese

3 Year Aged White Cheddar Cheese

$8.40
Aged Swiss Cheese

Aged Swiss Cheese

$10.50
Aged White Cheddar Cheese

Aged White Cheddar Cheese

$7.35
Cooper Sharp White American Cheese

Cooper Sharp White American Cheese

$40.00
Cooper Sharp Black Pepper American Cheese

Cooper Sharp Black Pepper American Cheese

$40.00
Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

$8.40
Smoked Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Smoked Sharp Cheddar Cheese

$8.40
Cooper Sharp Yellow American Cheese

Cooper Sharp Yellow American Cheese

$40.00
Cooper Sharp White American Cheese

Cooper Sharp White American Cheese

$40.00
Cooper Sharp Black Pepper American Cheese

Cooper Sharp Black Pepper American Cheese

$40.00
Smoked Creamy White American Cheese

Smoked Creamy White American Cheese

$7.88
Schreiber Yellow American Cheese

Schreiber Yellow American Cheese

$26.50
Smoked Creamy Black Pepper American Cheese

Smoked Creamy Black Pepper American Cheese

$8.40
Schreiber White American Cheese

Schreiber White American Cheese

$26.50
Cooper Sharp Yellow American Cheese

Cooper Sharp Yellow American Cheese

$40.00
Spicy Cajun Cheese Curds

Spicy Cajun Cheese Curds

$8.40
Natural Cheese Curds

Natural Cheese Curds

$8.40
Garlic & Herb Cheese Curds

Garlic & Herb Cheese Curds

$8.40

We're Here to Help

Delivery & Returns

Read More

Contact Us

Read More

About Us

Read More

Frequently asked questions

How is your cheese shipped?

We primarily use UPS for shipping. We ship from New Holland, PA; depending on the destination, we require UPS 3 Day Select. You can view our shipping policy for more details.
What shipping speed should I choose?

We recommend 2-day or faster shipping for warm climates and remote destinations. For shipments to the Midwest and West Coast, we require a minimum of 3-day Select. View our shipping policy for complete details.
Are your cheeses gluten free?

Yes, all our cheeses are gluten free!

Savor the Quality

Share the Tradition